Early McCullough History:

This information was compiled by Richard McCullough of the Coffee County Tennessee McCulloughs. Many thanks to Richard for sharing his research.

The first of the name was Cullagh, son of Allil, who was killed in a skirmish with the Picts in 864. As far back as the 11th century, this ancient family held the lands of Cardoness, Myretoun, Ardwall, and Kirkcudbrightshire. The McCullough name first appears in records in 1296 when Thomas Maculagh del counte de Wyggetone, as the sheriff of Wigtownshire, Scotland, rendered homage to king Edward I. He appears in records again in 1305 with his brother Michel, as a juror on inquest at Berwick, Scotland. Other early McCulloughs include Sir Patrick McCoulagh and Gilbert McCoulaghe in Galloway, Scotland in 1354. Records show that Sir Patrick McCoulagh was awarded “100 marks in recompense of his suffering and loss of lands in Scotland for his allegiance to the King of England in 1360.” Patrick Mackullouch was listed as being the vicar of Arbroath, Scotland.

Click here to read more from Richard’s McCullough Reasearch.

The McCullough Migration to the United States:
This information was also compiled by Richard McCullough of the Coffee County Tennessee McCulloughs. Many thanks to Richard for sharing his research.

After the death of Sir Godfrey McCulloch in 1697, the first of our line, as did many other McCulloch’s, left the Galloway area of Scotland. Some went to Ireland, and others went to North America. Two McCullough men (one spelled McCullough and the other McCullock) left Scotland and settled in the Augusta County, previously Orange County area of Virginia. Records do not indicate the exact area of Scotland they left, but due to dates taken from ship registries, logic suggest that after the death of the clan chieftain, they left Galloway for America. In November of 1698, John McCullough boarded the Perry and Lane in Liverpool, England, and set sail for Virginia. Thomas McCullock boarded the John Baptist in London, England in December of the same year and also sailed to Virginia. Records do not indicate which one these two was our ancestor, since they boarded the ship in England, they most likely had come from Scotland. There were no major sea ports on the Atlantic side of Scotland and those wishing to go to America or Canada would sail from either a British or an Irish harbor. If they had lived in Ireland, they mo likely would have sailed from a port there. This is only speculation and cannot be proven. It is very interesting to note that the first white settlement in America was established only 91 years earlier. The Jamestown settlement in Virginia was established in 1607. Only a fraction of the immigrants from the British Isles had entered North America by 1700. It would be nearly 76 years before the American Revolution would began.

Click here
to read more from Richard’s McCullough Reasearch.

Our McCullough Line

Information from VA rolls and Augusta County Court records indicate that Mr. McCullough (either Thomas or John) and Mrs. McCullough were living in Virginia in 1700 and had the following children: (* indicates our line)

Isaac McCullough Born: 1717
James McCullough* Born: 1719
Thomas McCullough Born: 1720

Virginia muster rolls indicate that Isaac and James served in the Virginia militia in 1742 under Captain John Christian. Thomas also served in the Virginia Militia under Captain John Smith. Thomas was killed in the battle of King’s Mountain in South Carolina on October 3, 1780. The battle at King’s Mountain was an important victory for the American colonist and is said to have been the turning point in the war for independence. Isaac later moved into the area of what is now Hawkins County, Tennessee and many of his descendants are still living in that area. James married and had a son, William McCullough. William was born in 1740 and married Ann Eve in 1761. Records indicate that they had the following children: (* indicates our line)

Henry
Thomas*
Joseph
Mary
James
Nancy
William
Samuel
Susannah
Alexander
Born: 1762
Born: 1764
Born: 1767
Born: 1768
Born: 1770
Born: 1773
Born: 1776
Born: 1779
Born: 1781
Born: 1783
(married Nancy Jones)
(married Mary McCullough)
(married Betsy Brannum)
(married Thomas Chambers)
(married Comfort Stevens)
(married Margaret Porter)
(married John Long)
(married Patsey Martin)

Thomas, Henry, Joseph, Samuel, and William left Virginia for what is n Greene County, Tennessee. The area was governed by North Carolina in those days. The Augusta County area of Virginia, the Greene and Washington Counties of Tennessee (not yet a state), and the Rockingham County area North Carolina all were in close proximity to the point where all three states had common boarders. Records indicate that the first and second generations McCulloughs in America settled in these areas.

Records indicate that the First McCullough to Coffee County was James Martin McCullough. He was born in Greene County, North Carolina in 1785. His Father Thomas McCullough and his mother, Mary McCullough were married in Greene County North Carolina. Thomas McCullough had four brothers listed in Greene County: Hen Joseph, William, and Samuel. Thomas and his brothers surveyed land in Greene and Knox Counties for road development, and served as Justices of the Peace for both counties. Thomas and Mary McCullough had five sons, Alexander, James Martin, Moses, Thomas, and William.

Thomas McCullough and Mary McCullough
(First generation of McCullough’s in Tennessee)

Alexander Born: 1782 married Patsie Martin
June 1813
James Martin Born: 1775 married Rhoda Brown
1816
Moses Born: 1787 married Polly Freed
Dec. 1814
Thomas Born: 1793 married Miriah Pinkston
Dec. 1820
then married Rhoda Kelly
Oct. 1830
William Born: 1796 married Lavina Myers

Greene County in those days encompassed nearly all of East Tennessee, and back then was part of the state of North Carolina. In 1779, North Carolina introduced the Washington Act, which opened up land west of the Appalachian Mountains. This are became Greene and Washington Counties of North Carolina, and in 1796, Tennessee became a state. On July 1, 1816, James married Rhoda Brown in Greene County. Records also show that James did own land in the Lick Creek area of Green County, however, the amount of land that he owned is unknown. James Martin’s brothers also married in Greene County as follows:Alexander McCullough married Patsie Martin June 1813
Moses McCullough married Polly Freed Dec. 1814
Thomas McCullough married Miriah Pinkston Dec. 1820
And Rhoda Kelly Oct. 1830
William McCullough married Lavina Myers

Early Indiana McCullough History
A Brief Sketch of the McCullough Family
Prepared August 1927 - by Willis A. McCullough

The ancestry of the McCullough family is of the Scottish origin as shown by the name. The first part of the name, “Mac”, means son, “Cull” means foot, and “Lough”, means lake. Hence the origin and meaning of the name McCullough is “The Son at the Foot of the Lake” At present it is not definitely known when the first McCullough came to America, but the most reliable information indicates that three brothers came from and landed in Pennsylvania before the War in which America gained her independence from England. Two of the three brothers later made their way southward into the region of Virginia and eastern Tennessee. The other one of the three brothers made his way westward and some of his descendents are now found to be in North Central Indiana where one of his descendents who was a mill-wright finally located.

William McCullough is the first of our ancestor of whom we have definite information, and evidence indicates that originated from one of the two brothers that went southward from Pennsylvania. The similarity if the Christian names of the McCulloughs found in the different parts of the country helps to confirm the belief that all in America who bear the name originated from someone if the three brothers who landed in Pennsylvania in the very early part of the history of our country, although the are some modified forms of the spelling of the name. Scott’s spell “Cull” and “Coll” to mean “foot” and “Lough” or “Loch” to mean “Lake”.

William McCullough was born in Tennessee in 1796, and his wife Lavina Myers, was born in 1798. They were married in the year 1816, which was the year that Indiana became a state.

Our Federal Government purchased a large part of Indiana from the Indians in the year 1818. That tract included almost half the state and was located in the central part. That was the first purchase made in Indiana after Indiana became one of the states. The Indians were removed from the tract in 1820 and the government established a land office in the fall of 1821 and land was sold to the settlers as low as $1.25 per acre and the land was free from taxation for five years after purchasing. The state capital was located in Indianapolis in 1824. The above named conditions and the fact that the government made suitable provisions fir education were inducements which probably had much to do with William and Lavina (Myers) McCullough leaving Tennessee and making their way to Indiana, landing in the southwestern part of what in now Putnam County in the year 1829. [Click here to see one of William’s land grant documents (1837) in Adobe Acrobat© pdf format.]

When William came to Indiana there were no roads and immigrants found their way by following trails made by the Indians and the buffalos, or by the more reliable trail known as the “Whetzel Trail”. This was a trail marked out in 1819 by Jacob Whetzel, who blazed the trees thereby making a course from the southeastern part of Indiana to within about 20 miles if where Indianapolis now stands. The dangers that confronted immigrants from hostile Indians and wild animals also confronted William McCullough and his family as they came to their new home. The fact that the forests must be cleared in 1824 to lay out the streets in Indianapolis would emphasize the fact that William McCullough also faced the task of providing shelter for his family and clearing the forests and preparing the land for cultivation so as to provide for food. William McCullough knew the dangers from disease, which lurked in the low lands, so he naturally sought a location on some of the higher lands where he succeeded in rearing a family of sixteen children, all of whom reached maturity. The youngest of the sixteen children was nineteen when his father died and all reared families of their own except one. William McCullough in 1863 and Moses, the only child to die unmarried, followed him within a few days, having contracted pneumonia from exposure while attending the funeral of the father.

I. West, the oldest son of William and Lavina Myers McCullough, was born in Tennessee in 1819 and came with his parents to Indianapolis when he was ten years of age. He purchased a farm adjoining to the McCullough homestead, where he located and lived the remainder of his life. He was married in 1841 to Matilda Mills, who died about 1856. He later married Rachel Paul, who was better known by many of the present generation as “Aunt Rachel”. West McCullough died in 1876, leaving a family of nineteen children.

II. Michael McCullough was born in Tennessee in 1820 and came to Indiana with the family in 1829. He was married to Eliza J. Zenor in 1812, located in Putnam County for a short time, then purchased a quarter section of land in Jackson Township, Clay County, Indiana where he lived until his death in 1873. He was unfortunate that he was deaf for a number of years.

III. Hyleigh McCullough was born in Tennessee in 1822, came to Indiana with the family, and married to Jesse Aker in 1840. Two children resulted from that marriage, Lemuel Aker and Nancy Ellen (Aker) Catterlin. After the death of Jesse Aker, Hyleigh married Nathaniel Modesitt and lived on a farm in Perry Township, Clay County, Indiana until her death in 1909.

IV. Thomas McCullough was born in Tennessee in 1823, was married to Lucretia Grable in 1843. He settled near the old homestead in Putnam County for a time, then purchased 120 acres of land in the center of Jackson Township, Clay County, Indiana and lived there until his death in 1894.

V. Alexander McCullough was born in Tennessee in 1824. He was married to Mary Payne, daughter of Robert Payne about the year 1850. He brought a large farm in the eastern part of Jackson Township, Clay County, Indiana, on which he settled and lived until his death, which occurred in 1902.

VI. Eleanor McCullough, better known as “Aunt Nellie”, was born in Tennessee in 1826. She was married to Bennett Payne, son of Robert Payne, about the year 1850. They settled for a short time near the old homestead in Putnam County, then purchased a farm in the eastern part of Jackson Township, Clay County, Indiana, and lived there until her death in 1897.

VII. Nancy McCullough was born in Tennessee in 1828, and married Jacob Mace in 18__. They bought a farm in Jackson Township, Clay County, Indiana, north of Asherville, where they lived for a short time. They sold the farm to Uncle Bill McCullough, and bought a farm in Harrison Township, Clay County, Indiana, north of Clay City. Jacob went to the war and gave his life helping to preserve the Union of our States. Nancy later married Nathaniel Cooperider, and then moved to Kansas, where she died in 18__.

VIII. William McCullough, known to this generation as “Uncle Bill” was born in Putnam County, Indiana in 130. He married Elizabeth Mace, bought 80 acres of land in Jackson Township, Clay County, Indiana, adjoining the farm of his brother Michael. Later he sold this farm to a coal speculator, named Jennings and bought a farm in Putnam County, consisting chiefly of Eel River bottom land, where he located and lived until his death, which occurred in 1903.

IX. James McCullough was born in 1832. It is not established whether he was born in Putnam County, Indiana or in Tennessee, as the parents made a trip back to the old home in Tennessee about that date. James McCullough married Mary Ann Mace, Daughter of Nicholas Mace, and a distant relative of Uncle Bill’s wife, purchased a farm in Putnam County, Indiana, near the old homestead where he lived for the remainder of his life. He died in 1914.

X. Francis McCullough was born in Putnam County, Indiana in 1834. He was married to Amanda mace, daughter of Nicholas Mace, settled on the old homestead for a short time, moved to Illinois and later went on to Oregon, where he died in _____.

XI. Jacob Newton McCullough was born in Putnam County, Indiana in 1836, and was married to Elizabeth Jane Mace, daughter of Nicholas Mace. He settled near the old homestead and lived there until after the death of his wife. Later he moved to Missouri and then to Arkansas. he died at Lone Oak, Arkansas, in ______.

XII. Lavina McCullough was born in Putnam County, Indiana in 1838, and was married to John Syester in 1856. They first settled near the old homestead, but soon moved to a farm in Parke County, Indiana. Later they moved to Terre Haute, Indiana and then to Brazil, Indiana, where she died in 1897

XIII. Moses McCullough was born in Putnam County, Indiana in 1839. He contracted pneumonia from exposure at the funeral of his father in 1863 and died within a few days, being the first if the family of sixteen children to die and the only one who was unmarried.

XIV. Matilda McCullough was born in Putnam County, Indiana in 1841. She was married to Oliver B. Johnson in 1863, and located on a farm, which they bought in the eastern part of Jackson Township, Clay County, Indiana, where she resided until her death in 1918.

XV. Samuel McCullough was born in Putnam County, Indiana in 1843, and was married to Sarah Nees in 1863. He settled near the old homestead in Putnam County, Indiana for a short time and then purchased a farm in the southern part of Clay County, near Saline City, where he lived for the remainder of his life. He died about 1877.

XVI. Joseph Wright McCullough was born in Putnam County, Indiana in 1844. He was married to Sarah Caroline Cromwell, daughter of Owen Cromwell, lived for a short time near the old homestead and then located in the southern part of Clay County, near Brunswick, where Aunt Sarah died. He later married Catherine Myers, bought the Myers homestead in Putnam County, Indiana, moved to it and lived there until the death of Aunt Catherine. He then sold the farm to his eldest son, Oather, and married Caroline Maurer, and moved to her farm in Jackson Township, Clay County, Indiana, where he lived until his death March 29, 1917.

My Great Great Great Grandfather- WILLIAM MCCULLOUGH was born in Tennessee on September 11, 1796 and migrated to the south west part of Washington Township, Putnam County, Indiana in 1828. He was the First Known McCullough in Indiana. William married Lavina (Myers) McCullough born July 7, 1798 and had 16 children as follows: West b.1-15-1819, d. 8-18-1876, Michael b. 7-2-1820, d. 12-27-1875, Hyliegh b. 1-26-1822, d. 1909, Thomas J. b. 2-4-1823, d. 12-14-1894, Alexander b. 4-22-1824, d. 2-8-1902, Elenor b. 10-11-1826, d. 7-24-1897, Nancy 9-6-1828, d. 3-10-1902, William b. 6-30-1830, d. 2-23-1903, James b. 5-13-1832, d. 2-23-1914, Francis Marion b. 6-1-1834, d. ? Jacob Newton b. 5-3-1836, d. ?, Lavina b. 6-9-1838, d. 1897, Moses b. 8-31-1839, d. 1863, Matilda b. 5-18-1841, d. 1918, Samuel b. 2-18-1843, d. 1878, Joseph Wright b. 7-17-1844, d. 3-29-1917.

From : A HISTORY OF CLAY COUNTY, by William Travis, 1909 My Great Great Grandfather- WEST MCCULLOUGH was a native of Bullsgap Tennessee, born in 1818 and died in 1876. His wife Matilda (Mills) McCullough was born in North Carolina and died September, 1855, aged thirty-four years. They were united in marriage in Putnam county near Webster Mills and were the parents of eight children as follows: Levina, William Henry, Newton A., Vincent, Marion, John T., Millard, and Franklin. After the death of Mr. McCullough’s first wife he married Rachel J. Paul at Railsville, Putnam County, Indiana, by which into the union ten children were born as follows: Albert, Perry, Martha, Jane, Lee Nelson, Riley, and Eliza. West McCullough came to Indiana in 1928 with his parents who located in Putnam County. They returned to Tennessee, however and spent one year and then returned, making the journey by wagon. He grew to manhood in Putnam County

and entered government land, first building a log cabin in which his son William Henry, was born. Later he erected a large two story house. This farm contained about seven hundred acres and at the time of Mr. McCullough’s death, he was one of the prominent men of his county. Politically, he was a Jackson Democrat.My Great Grandfather- MARION MCCULLOUGH numbered among the successful agriculturists of Perry Township, Clay County, Indiana, was Marion McCullough, a man of industry, thrift and enterprise, whose general worth impresses those whom he comes in contact very strongly. A native of Putnam County, Indiana, being the fourth son in succession of birth of West and Matilda (Mills) McCullough. Reared and educated in his native township, Mr. McCullough remained with his parents until his marriage. Coming then to Clay County he lived for two years in Cass Township. On April 25, 1873, he bought one hundred and ten acres, a log house and a pole barn constituted the only improvements. Laboring with characteristic energy and ambition he cleared a large part of the place, and lived there until March 4, 1886. Selling out at that time, Mr. McCullough bought his farm in Section 3, Perry Township, and was busily employed in tilling the soil, having his one hundred and twenty acres of land in excellent yielding condition. His annual harvest were most satisfactory in quantity and quality. He and his family occupied the log house which stood upon the place when he bought it until November, 1903, when they moved into the substantial and conveniently arranged frame house which he built. He carried on general farming and stock-raising, in both branches of which he found signal success. On February 5, 1871, Mr. McCullough married Nancy C. Mace, who was born August 14, 1852, in Cass Township, Clay County. her father, Issac Mace, came from Tennessee, his native state, to Indiana, bought timbered land in Cass township, and was there engaged in tilling the soil until his death about 1856, at the age of fifty-two years. His wife whose name was Delaney Akre, survived him about a year. The Maces had nine children. Mr. and Mrs. McCullough have reared six children, namely Laura, Gildert, Franklin, Seth, Mack and Gladys. Politically Mr. McCullough supported the principles of the Democratic party at the polls were esteemed members of the Christian Church.